25 March 2008

Rent Vs Buy - Paarl

Here's a 2 bed apartment in Paarl for sale for R850 000 (R70 000 below market value the ad claims). It currently rents for R4 000 and if you take out a full bond the difference between the bond payments and rent is just over 2.5 times the rent itself. Here's the payment and ROI you can expect.













Down PaymentMonthly PaymentCash FlowAnnual IncomeROICap. Appr. Required
R0R10879.98R-6879.98R-82559.77
9.71%
R85000R9791.98R-5791.98R-69503.79-81.77%8.18%
R170000R8703.98R-4703.98R-56447.82-33.20%6.64%
R255000R7615.99R-3615.99R-43391.84-17.02%5.10%
R340000R6527.99R-2527.99R-30335.86-8.92%3.57%
R425000R5439.99R-1439.99R-17279.89-4.07%2.03%
R510000R4351.99R-351.99R-4223.91-0.83%0.50%
R595000R3263.99R736.01R8832.071.48%-1.04%
R680000R2176.00R1824.00R21888.053.22%-2.58%
R765000R1088.00R2912.00R34944.024.57%-4.11%
R850000R0.00R4000.00R48000.005.65%-5.65%

So a sub 6% ROI and that's before rates/levies, maintenance and vacancy costs. A 70% downpayment is required to break even on cash flow and even with a 50% downpayment you need 2% capital appreciation just to not lose any money at all.

There is also a R5000 a month rental subsidy offered, which is no doubt factored into the price and which you'll be paying back over 20 years. I bet that if nstead of a rental subsidy you ask for R60 000 off the asking price you'll get a quick 'no'. Everyone needs to protect their commissions.

No comments: